System and method of presenting search results

ABSTRACT

In a particular embodiment, a system to present search results is disclosed that includes a search system to retrieve search results from multiple data sources and to extract data from the search results. The system also includes a visualization system to generate a graphical user interface (GUI) including a visualization of data related to the search results and including multiple control options. The multiple control options include a first option and a second option related to the extracted data, where the first option is accessible to alter the visualization.

FIELD OF THE DISCLOSURE

The present disclosure is generally related to systems and methods ofsearching data sources.

BACKGROUND

In general, public information sources, such as the Internet, presentchallenges for information retrieval. The volume of informationavailable via the Internet grows daily, and search engine technologieshave scaled dramatically to keep up with such growth. Conventionally,search engines, such as those provided by Yahoo, Google, and others,utilize data collection technologies, such as spiders, bots, and webcrawlers, which are software applications that access web pages andtrace hypertext links in order to generate an index of web pageinformation. The data collected by such software applications istypically stored as pre-processed data on which search engines mayoperate to perform searches and to retrieve information.

Additionally, a vast amount of data exists that is not accessible to thepublic Internet (e.g., “dark web” data, internal data, internalapplication data, private data, subscription database data, other datasources, or any combination thereof). Such data can often be searchedvia private access interfaces, private search tools, other applicationprogram interfaces, or any combination thereof. Such information may besegregated from other information sources, requiring multipleinterfaces, multiple protocols, multiple formats, and different databasedrivers to access the data. Accordingly, information retrieval can becomplicated by the variety of data sources.

To improve the quality of search results and to remove “junk results,”search engines may include logic or tools to fine-tune the searchresults. In some instances, such fine-tuning may be based on relevanceto other users, on a number of links from other web pages to aparticular resource, or on a combination of information that is notspecific to a user's interests (i.e. the user's search and the questionrelated to the user's search). Additionally, with the volume of searchresults, even after fine-tuning, it often remains difficult to identifydesired information. Hence, there is a need for an improved system andmethod of searching distributed data sources.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

FIG. 1 is a block diagram of a particular illustrative embodiment of asystem to search data sources;

FIG. 2 is a block diagram of a second particular illustrative embodimentof a system to search data sources;

FIG. 3 is a block diagram of a third particular illustrative embodimentof a system to search data sources;

FIG. 4 is a flow diagram of a particular illustrative embodiment of amethod of searching data sources;

FIG. 5 is a flow diagram of a second particular illustrative embodimentof a method of searching data sources;

FIG. 6 is a flow diagram of a third particular illustrative embodimentof a method of searching data sources;

FIG. 7 is a flow diagram of a fourth particular illustrative embodimentof a method of searching data sources;

FIG. 8 is a flow diagram of a fifth particular illustrative embodimentof a method of searching data sources;

FIG. 9 is a flow diagram of a sixth particular illustrative embodimentof a method of searching data sources;

FIG. 10 is a flow diagram of a seventh particular illustrativeembodiment of a method of searching data sources;

FIG. 11 is a flow diagram of an eighth particular illustrativeembodiment of a method of searching data sources;

FIG. 12 is a flow diagram of a ninth particular illustrative embodimentof a method of searching data sources;

FIG. 13 is a flow diagram of a tenth particular illustrative embodimentof a method of searching data sources;

FIG. 14 is a flow diagram of an eleventh particular illustrativeembodiment of a method of searching data sources;

FIG. 15 is a flow diagram of a twelfth particular illustrativeembodiment of a method of searching data sources;

FIG. 16 is a flow diagram of a thirteenth particular illustrativeembodiment of a method of searching data sources;

FIG. 17 is a flow diagram of a particular illustrative embodiment of amethod of query refinement;

FIG. 18 is a flow diagram of a particular illustrative embodiment of amethod of goal-oriented searching;

FIG. 19 is a flow diagram of a second particular illustrative embodimentof a method of goal-oriented searching;

FIG. 20 is a flow diagram of a particular illustrative embodiment of amethod of presenting search results;

FIG. 21 is a flow diagram of a second particular illustrative embodimentof a method of presenting search results;

FIG. 22 is a flow diagram of a third particular illustrative embodimentof a method of presenting search results;

FIG. 23 is a flow diagram of a fourth particular illustrative embodimentof a method of presenting search results; and

FIGS. 24-39 are diagrams of particular illustrative embodiments of agraphical user interface to search data sources.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

In a particular embodiment, a system is disclosed to search one or moredata sources. The system includes an interface to a network, avisualization system to provide a search interface to a destinationdevice via the network, and a search system. The search systemcommunicates with the interface to receive a query from the destinationdevice. The search system proxies the query to search multiple datasources, receives search results from the multiple data sources, andextracts data from the search results. The system also includes apersonalization system to personalize the search results from themultiple data sources to a particular user.

In a particular embodiment, a system to present search results isdisclosed that includes a search system to retrieve search results frommultiple data sources and to extract data from the search results. Thesystem also includes a visualization system to generate a graphical userinterface (GUI) including a visualization of data related to the searchresults and including multiple control options. The multiple controloptions include a first option and a second option related to theextracted data, where the first option is accessible to alter thevisualization.

In another particular illustrative embodiment, a method of presentingsearch results is disclosed that includes receiving search results frommultiple data sources and extracting data from the search results. Themethod also includes dynamically generating a graphical user interfaceincluding a visualization of data related to the search results andincluding multiple control elements related to the extracted data. Themultiple control elements include a first control element to alter thevisualization.

In still another particular embodiment, a method of presenting searchresults is disclosed that includes receiving search results andgenerating a graphical user interface (GUI) including one or morevisualizations of data related to the search results and includingmultiple selectable options. The multiple selectable options include afirst selectable option to select between the one or more visualizationsand a second selectable option to adjust the data.

FIG. 1 is a block diagram of a particular illustrative embodiment of asystem 100 to search data sources. The system 100 includes a user device102 that can communicate with a search system 104 via a network 106. Ina particular illustrative embodiment, the network 106 may be a publicnetwork (such as the Internet), a private network (such as a corporateintranet, a virtual private network, an enterprise system, or anycombination thereof), or any combination thereof. In general, multipleremote devices, such as the user device 102, can communicate with thesearch system 104 via the network 106. In a particular illustrativeembodiment, the user device 102 may represent any device having accessto the Internet and that is capable of executing an Internet browserapplication, such as a computer, a web-enabled mobile phone, a personaldigital assistant (PDA), a set-top box device, or any combinationthereof.

Additionally, the search system 104 may communicate with one or moreexternal data sources 108, such as web sites, commercial databases,libraries, government sites, internal or private data sources,user-generated data (i.e. meta-data, user-tagged data, web logs (blogs),or other user-generated data), other data sources, or any combinationthereof. Such external data sources 108 may include structured data(such as pre-processed data, database records, other structured data, orany combination thereof), semi-structured data (such as tagged data,e.g., hypertext markup language (HTML); extensible markup language(XML); formatted data; or any combination thereof), and unstructureddata (such as text). In a particular illustrative embodiment, thestructured data may include indexed data, such as data that is assembledusing an automated software application, such as a spider, a “bot,” asoftware agent, or other software, which is commonly used by searchengine applications to index data sources for later retrieval. Thesearch system 104 can communicate via the network 106 with the userdevice 102, with the external data sources 108, and with other devicesthrough a firewall 110, which provides security to the search system 104to prevent undesired intrusions.

The search system 104 includes an interface 112 that is responsive tothe network 106, processing logic 114 that is coupled to the interface112, and memory 116 that is accessible to the processing logic 114. In aparticular illustrative embodiment, the search system 104 may includemultiple servers having separate processors and memory devices, whichmay cooperate to provide the search system 104. The memory 116 includesa data acquisition module 120, including an extract-transform-load (ETL)feature, that is executable by the processing logic 114 to acquire datafrom the external data sources 108 and to extract, transform and loadthe acquired data into one or more data stores, including a documentdata storage 134. In a particular illustrative embodiment, the ETLfeature of the data acquisition module 120 can identify missinginformation (such as missing fields, missing meta-data, garbledinformation, omitted data, or any combination thereof) and can makeprobabilistic determinations to assign values in lieu of the missinginformation. For example, in a particular illustrative embodiment, thedata acquisition module 120 identifies missing assignee informationassociated with a particular patent and makes a probabilisticdetermination to extrapolate a likely assignee of the patent.

The memory 116 may also include a search module 122 having an ETLfeature. The search module 122 can be executed by the processing logic114 to receive a query, to generate queries to other search engines andto one or more of the other data sources 108, and to extract data fromsearch results (using the ETL feature). In a particular illustrativeembodiment, the search module 122 may include a query learner to monitoruser interactions with search results, to receive user input related torelevance of selected search results, to determine a desired resultbased on the user input and the initial query, and to generate newqueries based on determining the desired result.

The memory 116 may also include a data storage module 124 that isexecutable by the processing logic 114 to store retrieved data,metadata, statistics, other data, or any combination thereof. The memory116 may include a user data storage 132, a document data storage 134, afinancial data storage 136, a classification information data storage138, other data storage 140, or any combination thereof. The user datastorage 132 can include user-provided tags (descriptions, meta-data,categories, or other information) related to documents or dataassociated with other stored information. The user data storage 132 canalso include correlations to user-created data, such as spreadsheetdata, table data, document data, web log (blog) data, other data, or anycombination thereof.

The document data storage 134 can include meta-data about documents(e.g., ownership data, location data, authorship data, date information,classification data, publication/source data, relationship/referencedata, embedded tags, other data, or any combination thereof). In aparticular illustrative, non-limiting embodiment, the document datastorage 134 can include data related to particular structured documents,such as patents, Published Patent Applications, and other structureddocuments. In such an instance, the document data storage 134 caninclude data related to the title, the inventors, the assignee, thepriority data, the claims (e.g., number of claims, number of independentclaims, claim terms, types of claims, other information, or anycombination thereof), the Abstract (e.g., text of the abstract, keywordsextracted from the abstract, a number of words in the Abstract, otherinformation related to the abstract, or any combination thereof), thefile history (e.g., whether claims were amended during prosecution, alist of cited references, links to file wrapper documents, otherinformation, or any combination thereof), excerpts from thespecification that relate to search terms, or any combination thereof.The document data storage 134 may also include various documents, suchas patents, journals, research papers, white papers, product documents,web sites (i.e. as a stored source file), articles, press releases,books, manuals, presentations, reports, sales information, any otherdocument containing text, or any combination thereof.

In a particular illustrative embodiment, the financial data storage 136can include revenues, profits, credit history, price-to-earnings (P/E)ratio, industry data for classification of tax records, Securities andExchange Commission (SEC) reports, stock prices, stock trends, otherfinancial data, or any combination thereof, that is related to eachparticular company. In another particular illustrative embodiment, thefinancial data storage 136 may also include financial data related toindividuals, organizations, associations, other entities that havefinancial information, or any combination thereof. In still anotherparticular illustrative embodiment, the financial data storage 136 caninclude other financial information that can be related to any categoryof interest.

In a particular illustrative embodiment, particular financial data maybe added to the financial data storage 136 to provide customized data toa particular enterprise. The financial data storage 136 may also includeinformation that is not financial, but that is related to an entity'sstructure, size, organization, or other information. For example, thefinancial data storage 136 may include employee records, number ofemployees, subsidiary information, corporate officer information, taxjurisdictions, governmental grants (such as a Small Business InnovativeResearch (SBIR) grants, Small Business Administration (SBA) loans, othergovernmental grants), press release data, contracts, and other data thatis related to the financial data of a particular company, entity,individual, association, or enterprise. In another particularillustrative embodiment, the financial data storage 136 can includeenterprise resource planning (ERP) data, sales data, customerrelationship management (CRM) data, other enterprise data, or anycombination thereof.

In a particular illustrative embodiment, the classification informationdata storage 138 can include multiple industry classifications and datarelated to those classifications. For example, the classificationinformation data storage 138 can include a number of companies in eachindustry, a number of employees of each industry, average salaries ofemployees, revenues of companies, average revenues, average payroll,average number of companies per classification, other information, orany combination thereof. In a particular illustrative embodiment, theclassification information data storage 138 can include locationinformation, which may be summarized by region, state, city, zip codeinformation, or any combination thereof. In a particular illustrativeembodiment, the classification information data storage can includenormalized classifications that are translated from North AmericanIndustry Classification System (NAICS) classifications, StandardIndustry Classification (SIC) system classifications, United StatesPatent and Trademark Office classifications, internationalclassification systems, legal classification systems, Reuter'sclassifications systems (news release categories), other news servicesclassification systems, or any combination thereof. Additionally, theclassification information system can include normalized translationsthat are translated from any industry-specific taxonomy, includingmedical indices, semiconductor industry classifications, consumerproduct classifications, other classifications, or any combinationthereof. The classification data storage 138 also includes associationsbetween classifications from various sources. In a particularillustrative embodiment, the classification data storage system 138 caninclude buyer information and supplier information that is related to aparticular industry. In a particular illustrative embodiment, theclassification data storage system 138 can include logic to translate orto integrate classifications from various classification systems to anintermediate classification system.

In a particular illustrative embodiment, other data storage 140 caninclude legal information, such as litigation-related data, includinglength of cases (start date and end date), decisions/outcomes of thecases, damages requested, damages granted, winners, actions of the cases(i.e. injunction, transfer, court-ordered royalties, other information),the plaintiffs, the defendants, the asserted intellectual propertyinformation, jurisdiction information, location information (of theparties, of the court, etc.), rates of settlement, dismissal, verdict,unknown, settlement, statistics, other data, or any combination thereof.The other data storage 140 can also include corporate legal departmentinformation, including licensing information, names of legal departmentcontacts, other information, or any combination thereof. In a particularillustrative embodiment, the other data storage 140 can also includecorporation data, Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) filings (i.e.litigation information, including settlements, on-going litigation, andother litigation information extracted from the SEC filings),legislative information, other data, or any combination thereof. Inanother particular illustrative embodiment, the other data storage 140can also include person information (i.e. telephone whitepages,yellowpages, other people “find” features, or any combination thereof).

In a particular illustrative embodiment, the user data storage 132, thedocument data storage 134, the financial data storage 136, theclassification information data storage 138, and the other data storage140 may be stored at different servers, which may be in differentgeographic locations. In another particular embodiment, the user datastorage 132, the document data storage 134, the financial data storage136, the classification information data storage 138, and the other datastorage 140 may be stored at a storage server device. In anotherparticular illustrative embodiment, the user data storage 132, thedocument data storage 134, the financial data storage 136, theclassification information data storage 138 and the other data storage140 may be stored in a single data store, which may be accessible to oneor more servers.

The memory 116 also includes an applications module 126 that isexecutable by the processing logic 114 to generate graphical maps,charts, dashboard elements, other visual representations, or anycombination thereof, for visual analysis of particular data elements,including search results, data derived from the search results,corporate data, industry data, document data, document statistics, otherdata, or any combination thereof. Additionally, the applications module126 can be executed by the processing logic 114 to reverse engineer userqueries, to track user interactions with search results, and to evaluateexplicit user feedback to train a query learner application and adocument learner application and to automatically generate new searches.Further, the applications module 126 can be executed by the processinglogic 114 to analyze the search results, to apply rules derived from thedocument learner, to refine the search results, and to produceadditional information about the search results.

The memory 116 also includes an operations and management module 128that is executable by the processing logic 114 to manage subscriberaccounts, to manage individual sessions, to generate alerts and othercommunications, and to control a user experience with the search system104. Depending on the particular implementation, the memory 116 can alsoinclude other modules 130 that can be executed by the processing logic114, such as a graphical user interface (GUI) generator to generate agraphical user interface, including multiple selectable options.

In a particular illustrative embodiment, the search system 104 mayprovide a graphical user interface (GUI) that may be rendered within anInternet browser application of a remote computing device, such as theuser device 102. The GUI may request a username and password, which canbe entered via the user device 102 to access the search system 104. Thesearch system 104 receives a username and password via the network 106,verifies the username and password using the operations and managementmodule 128, and retrieves subscriber account information associated withthe username and password. For example, the search system 104 mayretrieve stored information, including search information, messages,stored analysis, and other information. The search system 104 maygenerate a GUI that includes selected portions of the storedinformation.

In a particular illustrative embodiment, the search system 104 cansearch structured data, semi-structured data, and unstructured data fromone or more data sources, can merge search results from each of the datasources, and can provide the search results to the user via a GUI. In aparticular embodiment, the processing logic 114 may execute the dataacquisition module 120 to extract data from documents associated withthe search results and to calculate statistics related to the documents.The processing logic 114 may access the search module 122 to generatequeries based on the extracted data or user metadata (such as a roleassigned to a particular user, e.g., an administrator role, a guestrole, a user role, another role, or any combination thereof). Theprocessing logic 114 performs a secondary search related to theextracted data or metadata. The search system 104 may augment the searchresults with results from the secondary search.

In a particular illustrative example, the search system 104 may search avariety of data sources using one or more keywords (which may beprovided by a user via the user device 102). The search system 104 mayreceive search results that satisfy the query string. Each search resultmay be associated with a particular document, which may includestructured data, semi-structured data, unstructured data, or anycombination thereof. The search system 104 may extract data from eachdocument, such as ownership data (i.e. an assignee, an author, etc.) andmay generate a secondary query based on the extracted data. For example,the search system 104 may extract ownership data and location data fromeach of the documents, where the ownership data identifies a corporationthat is associated with the document and where the location dataidentifies a location associated with the corporation, with theinventors, or any combination thereof. The search system 104 may utilizethe extracted data to generate a secondary query, which the searchsystem 104 may use to search the financial database 136, theclassification information data 138, and the other data 140 forsecondary data related to the identified corporations or related toother meaningful entities (such as a person's contact information).

In a particular illustrative embodiment, the search system 104 mayutilize data derived from the secondary search of the classificationinformation data 138 to identify industry classifications. The searchsystem 104 may utilize the identified industry classifications tocategorize or classify each of the search results with one or more ofthe industry classifications. Thus, classification data may be utilizedto normalize retrieved data across distributed data sources and datatypes, including structured and unstructured data sources. In aparticular embodiment, the search system 104 may associated each of thesearch results into multiple categories, including an industry category,a date category, a geographic location category, a document sourcecategory, other categories, or any combination thereof. In a particularillustrative embodiment, the search system 104 may associate eachdocument with an industry classification that corresponds to the ownerof the document (i.e. the assignee, the source, etc.). Additionally, thesearch system 104 may associate each document with a particular dateassociated with the publication, the priority date (i.e. patent prioritydate), or other date related information. Further, the search system 104may associate each document with a geographic location that is relatedto the ownership data. The search system 104 can generate a GUI thatincludes the search results and includes multiple control options basedon the industry classifications, which may be selected to refine theview of the search results. For example, at least one of the controloptions can be a negation control option, which can be selected toremove items from the search results that are associated with aparticular industry classification.

In a particular illustrative embodiment, the search system 104 cangenerate a graphical user interface and provide the graphical userinterface to the user device 102 via the network 106. The graphical userinterface can include a text input, a graphical map having multipleselectable graphic elements, links, menu options, or any combinationthereof. In a particular embodiment, the graphical user interfaceincludes search results, statistical data derived from the searchresults, and secondary data related to the search results. The graphicaluser interface can provide multiple different views of the searchresults to allow a user to visualize the same search results fromdifferent perspectives. Further, the graphical user interface may allowa user to share a snapshot of the search results with another user viathe network 106. While the data available from the multiple data sourcesmay change over time, the snapshot represents a picture of the searchresults at a point in time.

In a particular illustrative embodiment, the snapshot represents astored instance of particular search parameters. The search system 104can store the date and time that the particular snapshot is taken, andany modifications from previous stored snapshots (i.e. versioning). Thesearch system 104 may store the search parameters. During a saveprocess, the search system 104 may prompt a user to designate whetherand how he or she wishes to be notified by an alert under particularcircumstances, such as when the saved search parameters uncover a newsearch result. The server system 104 can generate an alert (such as anemail, a text message, a pager notification, instant messaging, a lettervia the United States Postal Service, a phone call, other alerts, or anycombination thereof). In a particular embodiment, when a user logs intothe search system 104, the search system 104 may provide a graphicaluser interface to bring the user up-to-date with respect to any changesto the search results since the last time the user logged into thesearch system 104. In another particular illustrative embodiment, thesearch system 104 can apply user-specific filters to filter out searchresults based on implicit or explicit user input.

FIG. 2 is a block diagram of a second particular illustrative embodimentof a distributed system 200 to search data sources. The system 200includes the search system 104, which may communicate with an enterprisesystem 202 via a public network 206, such as the Internet. Theenterprise system 202 can be a corporation, a law firm, a businessentity, an individual, or any combination thereof.

In general, the search system 104 may communicate with the enterprisesystem 202 via the public network 206 through a firewall 214, whichprevents unauthorized access to a private network 216 (such as arestricted access network) associated with the search system 104. In aparticular embodiment, the search system 104 may include multipleservers that communicate over a local area network (private network216), which the firewall 214 can isolate from the public network 206 toprevent unauthorized access.

The search system 104 and the enterprise system 202 can communicate withexternal data systems 208 and remote devices 210 and 212 via the publicnetwork 206. In a particular illustrative embodiment, the external datasystems 208 can include any number of data sources, including commercialdatabases, secure data, websites, governmental websites, public datarepositories, other data sources, or any combination thereof. The remotedevices 210 and 212 can include any device that is capable of executingan Internet browser application to access the public network 206. Theremote devices 210 and 212 can be computers, mobile telephone devices,portable digital assistants (PDAs), set-top box devices, other computingdevices, or any combination thereof. In a particular illustrativeembodiment, the remote device 210 may be associated with a user having asubscription with the search system 104, and the remote device 212 maybe associated with a user having an account with the enterprise system202.

The enterprise system 202 includes an interface responsive to thenetwork 206, processing logic 220 and memory 222 accessible to theprocessing logic 220. The memory 222 can include operations andmanagement systems 224 executable by the processing logic to manage useraccess and to manage a user experience with the enterprise system 202.The operations and management module 128 can also manage subscriberaccounts, to manage individual sessions, to generate alerts and othercommunications, and to control a user experience with the search system202.

The memory 222 can also include a search module 226 including anextract-transform-load (ETL) feature that can be executed by theprocessing logic 220 to receive a query, to generate queries to othersearch engines and to one or more of the other data sources 208, and toextract data from search results (using the ETL feature). In aparticular illustrative embodiment, the search module 226 may include aquery learner to monitor user interactions with search results, toreceive user input related to relevance of selected search results, todetermine a desired result based on the user input and the initialquery, and to generate new queries based on the determination.Additionally, the applications module 228 can be executed by theprocessing logic 220 to reverse engineer user queries, to track userinteractions with search results, and to evaluate explicit user feedbackto train a query learner application and a document learner applicationand to automatically generate new searches. Further, the applicationsmodule 228 can be executed by the processing logic 220 to analyze thesearch results, to apply rules derived from the document learner, and torefine the search results and produce additional information about thesearch results.

The memory 222 may also include a data storage module 230 that isexecutable by the processing logic 220 to store retrieved documents,user-created tags, data, metadata, statistics, other data, or anycombination thereof. The data storage module 230 may extract data fromsearch results, transform the extracted data, and load the extracteddata into a data storage, such as a database within the enterprise data232. The enterprise data 232 can include private data, which may includestructured data (such as database records), semi-structured data (suchas word-processing documents, tagged data, e.g., markup language dataincluding extensible markup language (XML) documents, hypertext markuplanguage (HTML) documents, other semi-structured data, or anycombination thereof), and unstructured data (i.e. text data, image data,audio data, or any combination thereof).

In a particular illustrative embodiment, a user may utilize the remotedevice 212 to access the enterprise system(s) 202 via the public network206. The user may access the search module 226 to search the enterprisedata 232 and to search external data systems 208 with a single query.The enterprise system 202 can extract data from the search results anduse the search module 226 and the applications module 228 to generate asecondary query based on the search results. The enterprise system 202can send the secondary query to the enterprise data 232, the externaldata systems 208, and the search system 104. Further, the enterprisesystem 202 can receive secondary data related to the secondary query andcan use the secondary data to augment the search results. The enterprisesystem 202 can merge the search results from the various data sources,can augment the merged search results with the secondary data, and cangenerate a graphical user interface including the augmented searchresults to the remote device 212.

FIG. 3 is a block diagram of a third particular illustrative embodimentof a system 300 to search data sources. The system 300 includes anapplications tier 302, an operations tier 304, a search tier 306, a datatier 308, and an extract-transform-load (ETL) tier 310, which includeprocessing logic and instructions executable by the processing logic tosearch data sources and to present search results.

The applications tier 302 can include multiple applications. Eachapplication can be a combination of logic (display, interaction, etc),portlets (visual components), and workflow (process of how componentswork together). The applications tier 302 includes a maps module 312that can be executed by processing logic to visually display landscapesand other visualizations. The applications tier 302 includes a searchmodule 312 that can be executed by processing logic to search multipledata sources, including structured data sources, semi-structured datasources, and unstructured data sources. The applications tier 302includes an analysis module 312 that can be executed by processing logicto process retrieved data to produce interactive visualizations foranalysis.

The maps module 312 can include logic 318 to control the display ofinformation, the graphical user interface for interacting with theinformation, and other functionality associated with visualizations(maps). The maps module 312 can include a portlet 320 to define visualcomponents for inclusion in a graphical user interface and a workflowmodule 322 to manage context and flow control. The search module 314controls a search interface, interactions with data sources, and howsearches are performed. The search module 314 can include logic 324 tocontrol the display of search results and to define a graphical userinterface for interacting with the search results, a portlet 326 todefine visual components associated with a search interface and aworkflow module 328 to manage context and flow control. The analysismodule 312 includes logic 330 to control the analysis of search results,a portlet 332 to define visual components associated with the analysis(such as a recommend results option). The analysis module 316 includes aworkflow module 334 to manage context, flow control, and performance ofthe analysis.

The operations tier 304 is adapted to manage sessions, to manage useraccounts, and to generally manage the user experience. The operationstier 304 can include functionality to provide administrative features,including security features such as authentication and authorizationfunctions. The operations tier 304 can include a session manager 336 totrack of user information, user preferences, permissions, and otherinformation. Additionally, the session manager 336 can track user input,implicit and explicit user interactions, store the input and theinteractions, and adjust the user experience accordingly, such as bypresenting search results in a particular manner to one user and in adifferent manner to another user. The operations tier 304 also includesa user manager 338 to manage permissions for each user and to manageinterconnections. The operations tier 304 includes a product manager 350to group applications and features for particular subscriptions. Theoperations tier 304 includes a billing manager 352 to track useractivity and to convert user activity to billable events. The operationstier 304 also includes a group manager 354 to track connections betweenusers. For example, the group manager 354 may maintain an address bookfor each user, a list of associations, and other information, which canbe used to facilitate collaboration between users. The operations tier304 can include an alert/communications manager 356 to communicate withusers via email, instant messages, web logs (“blogs”), really simplesyndication, documents, simple messaging system text messages, othermessages, or any combination thereof, to connect the user to other usersand to communicate up-to-date information to a selected user, such aswhen data is updated, automated search results are received, and so on.

The search tier 306 can include core components and libraries used forthe maps module 312, the search module 314 and the analysis module 316of the applications tier 302. The search tier 306 includes a searchengine 358, which can support Boolean searching (i.e. keyword searchinguses logical operators, including AND, OR, ANDNOT, and other operators)and which provides filtering and classification (grouping, clustering,other organization, or any combination thereof). The search engine 358can also support word proximity searches, allowing a user to search forinstances of search terms that are separated by less than auser-specified number words (e.g., a first term is within three words ofa second term). The search tier 306 also includes a search proxy 360that provides a search interface to other search engines, to other datasources, or any combination thereof, by generating search queries fromBoolean searches to match a desired query format for each data sourceand to query the data sources on behalf of the user. If Booleansearching is not supported by a particular data source, the search proxy360 can degrade and translate a Boolean search into another queryformat, provide a real-time indexing of other search data to allowsupport for advanced operators, or any combination thereof. In aparticular embodiment, advanced operators may include logical operators(AND, OR, NOT, and other operators), range filtering, attributefiltering, proximity searching, other search operations, or anycombination thereof. In an embodiment, a user Boolean query withproximity fields could be translated into query that could be sent tothe Google search engine. The search system can query the Google searchengine using the translated query, receive the search results,optionally download documents associated with the search results, indexthe resulting documents with advanced searching capabilities to producea temporary index, and perform the full query on the temporary index.

The search tier 306 includes a reduced extract-transform-load (mini-ETL)module 362 that can be used to parse retrieved documents into temporarytables mapped to an internal format. The search tier 306 also includes ametadata navigation module to extract statistics and patterns fromsearch results, to provide correlations for visual display, and to speednavigation through search results by permitting negation of categoriesof information, selection of specific information, and user-training ofquery learner and document learner applications. The search tier 306includes a query learner module 366 to reverse engineers a user's searchinto a better query by identifying “good” elements and “bad” elementsand by using the identified good and bad elements to generate a modifiedBoolean query learned from explicit and implicit user interactions.Implicit user interactions can include links followed by a user, lengthof time spent on a page by the user, commonality of terms betweendocuments associated with links followed by the user, and other implicitinformation. The explicit user interactions include document ratingssupplied by the user for selected items in a list of search results. Thesearch tier 306 includes a personalization system 368 to track eachuser's input, transaction history, search history, and actions and makesrecommendations about documents. The search tier 306 also includes avisualization engine 370 to render internal document data, metadata, anddimensions into various interactive visualizations. The search tier 306may also include other systems and modules, including algorithms, corelibraries to extract patterns, statistics, and otherwise data mineinformation from documents, and other applications.

The data module 308 can include user data 374, including userpreferences, administrative information, and other user account relateddata. The data module 308 can include personalization/history data thattracks user interactions, explicit feedback, and implicit feedback. Thedata module 308 includes a document database 378 including multipletables to store document elements. The data module 308 also includes anattribute database 380 to store information about document attributes,correlations between documents, classifications associated withdocuments, other information, or any combination thereof.

The ETL tier 310 is adapted to extract information from documentsreceived from any source (local, remote, or any combination thereof) andto convert the information to a “clean” format for internal use. The ETLtier 310 acquires the information using an acquisition module 382,extracts the information using an extraction module 384, and cleans ornormalizes the information using a clean/normalize module 386. The ETLtier 310 may also classify search results in “real-time” using aclassifier module 388. The classifier module 388 may be trained based onuser interactions, based on vertical data sets, or any combinationthereof. An example of a vertical data set can be a taxonomy thatincludes multiple categories or classification. The multiple categoriesor classifications can have associated documents, which can be utilizedto train the classifier module 388 about what types of information areincluded within a particular category or classification. For example,the United States Patent and Trademark Office classification system isorganized hierarchically and each classification includes multipledocuments that may be used to train the classifier module 388.

The classifier module 388 performs dynamic correlations between searchresults, based on metadata, content within particular search results,ownership data, authorship data, data about the data source, and otherinformation. The classifier module 388 may use such dynamic correlationsto make probabilistic determinations about missing information, such asassignee information related to a particular patent document. In aparticular illustrative, non-limiting example, the classifier module 338can make a make a probabilistic determination to identify a likelyassignee of a patent, even when the records at the United States Patentand Trademark Office do not include assignee information (i.e. theclassifier module 388 can guess likely corporate owners for particularpatents that appear to be unassigned). While the above-example isprovided in the context of patents, the classifier module 388 can beadapted to make probabilistic determinations in a variety of contexts inorder to augment search results. Such information may be presentedwithin a graphical user interface in such a way that the probabilisticdeterminations can be identified as compared to retrieved data. The ETLtier 310 may utilize the load module 390 to store documents, dataextracted from the documents, probabilistic determinations,classification data, correlations, and other information related tosearch results. The ETL tier 310 can use a monitor/alert module to applyuser profiles/filters to each document for special alerts. For example,the search system 300 may support publish/subscribe methodologies, suchas a really simple syndication technique, to provide updates and noticesto users when information of interest to the user is acquired.

In a particular illustrative embodiment, the search system 300 mayinclude a single server. In another particular illustrative embodiment,the search system 300 may include multiple servers having processinglogic and memory accessible to the processing logic to provide searchand visualization functionality.

In a particular illustrative embodiment, the search system 300 mayperform a first search based on a Boolean query provided by a user usingthe search tier 306. The operations tier 304 may coordinate theoperation of the applications tier 302 to produce a graphical userinterface and to provide the graphical user interface to a destinationdevice associated with the user. The search system 300 may acquiredocument data using the ETL tier 310 and may assemble information aboutthe user using the data tier 308. The search system 300 may utilize dataextracted by the ETL tier 310 to generate a secondary query, which thesearch tier 306 may use to search one or more data sources to acquiresecondary data. The search system 300 may augment the search resultswith the secondary data. For example, the search system 300 may acquirefinancial data (secondary data) based on ownership information extractedfrom the search results (extracted data). The search system 300 mayprovide the financial data in the form of a visualization, such as anindustry visualization, that can be related to the search results. Auser may switch between visualizations of the data and search resultsassociated with the data by interacting with user selectable elements ofa graphical user interface.

In a particular illustrative embodiment, a system may include a searchsystem 300 that includes a search tier to retrieve search results frommultiple data sources and to extract data from the search results. Thesystem may also include a classification system, such as the classifier388 within the ETL tier 310, to associate each of the search resultswith at least one classification based on the extracted data. The systemcan also include a visualization system 370 to generate a graphical userinterface (GUI) including data related to the search results andincluding multiple control options. The multiple control options caninclude a first option related to the extracted data and a second optionrelated to the at least one classification.

FIG. 4 is a flow diagram of a particular illustrative embodiment of amethod of searching data sources. At 402, a search system provides agraphical user interface (GUI) to a destination device, where the GUIincludes a text input and a graphical map having multiple selectablegraphic elements, where each selectable graphic element is associatedwith a category of information. Advancing to 404, the search systemreceives data related to a selection of one of the multiple selectablegraphic elements. Proceeding to 406, the search system sends a query tomultiple data sources in response to receiving the data. The query caninclude a search term related to the category of information associatedwith the selection. Continuing to 408, the search system receives searchresults based on the query, where each search result is associated witha document. Moving to 410, the search system extracts data from eachdocument, where the data includes ownership information, locationinformation, and other attributes associated with each document.Proceeding to 412, the search system generates a secondary query basedon the extracted data to the one or more data sources to derivesecondary data to augment the search results. Advancing to 414, thesearch system associates each search result with at least one categorybased on the secondary data. Continuing to 416, the search systemgenerates a graphical user interface including the search results. Themethod terminates at 418.

In a particular illustrative embodiment, the search system can generatea first graphical user interface including a first graphical map. Inresponse to receiving an input, the search system can perform a searchand generate a second graphical user interface including a secondgraphical map having multiple selectable elements related to the secondsearch results. In a particular illustrative embodiment, the graphicalmap may include a geographical representation of the search results. Ina particular illustrative embodiment, each of the multiple selectableelements of the graphical map can include a dimension parameter relatedto a relative number of associated documents. For example, in aparticular illustrative embodiment, each of the multiple selectableelements of the first graphical map, the second graphical map, or anycombination thereof can include a color parameter related to a relativenumber of associated documents. A large number of documents may berepresented using a red color while a small number of documents may berepresented in blue. In particular implementations, the color parametersassociated with large and small document spaces may vary. In analternative embodiment, the user may modify the color representations ofdocument spaces on the fly by interacting with selectable indicatorsprovided within a graphical user interface.

In a particular illustrative embodiment, the search system may issue atext query from a database query. For example, at 406, the search systemsends a query to multiple data sources in response to receiving thedata. One such data source may include a database. The search system mayreceive data from the database, generate a text query from the receiveddata and issue the text query to one or more data sources, furtheraugmenting the search results.

FIG. 5 is a flow diagram of a second particular illustrative embodimentof a method of searching data sources. At 502, the search systemreceives search results from one or more data sources, which can includean unstructured data source (e.g., text data, image data, video data,audio data, or other unstructured data). Moving to 504, the searchsystem extracts characteristics from the search results. Proceeding to506, the search system generates a secondary query based on theextracted characteristics. Continuing to 508, the search system receivessecond search results based on the secondary query that are related tothe search results. Advancing to 510, the search system derives a set ofindustry classifications from the second search results. Moving to 512,the search system associates each search result with at least oneclassification of the set of industry classifications. The search systemcan make additional classifications, including associating each searchresult with vertical classifications (such as database sourceinformation, document type information, ownership information, and otherclassifications), other classifications, or any combination thereof.Proceeding to 514, the search system augments the search results withthe second search results and the associations. Continuing to 516, thesearch system generates a graphical user interface that includes theaugmented search results. The method terminates at 518.

In a particular illustrative embodiment, the search system may receivesearch information, including search results and secondary data relatedto the search results. The search system can generate a graphical userinterface and provide the graphical user interface to a destinationdevice of a first user. The graphical user interface may includemultiple selectable options, which can be accessed to provide multipleviews of the search information. In a particular illustrativeembodiment, one of the multiple selectable options can include a searchsnapshot option to store a snapshot of the search information at a pointin time. The snapshot of the search information may include documents,search parameters, a date, a time, user information, information aboutsharing of the snapshot, alert information (if the particular userwishes to be notified when new information is available), or anycombination thereof. In another particular illustrative embodiment, oneof the multiple selectable options can include a collaboration option toshare the snapshot of the search information with a second user, and thesearch system may provide the snapshot of the search information to thesecond user using views associated with the second user. In yet anotherparticular illustrative embodiment, one of the multiple views caninclude a graphical map having multiple selectable graphic elements. Instill another particular embodiment, one of the views comprises a listof the search results and a control panel including multiple selectableindicators to filter the search results. The control panel can include agraphical element providing statistical data related to the searchresults.

FIG. 6 is a flow diagram of a third particular illustrative embodimentof a method of searching data sources. At 602, a search system receivesa query string. Advancing to 604, the search system cleanses/normalizesthe query string. The search system may cleanse the query string byreplacing the keywords or the query structure to match the querystructures for each of a variety of data sources (i.e. by “proxying” thequery). Moving to 606, the search system sends the cleansed/normalizedquery string to one or more data sources. Proceeding to 608, the searchsystem receives search results from the one or more data sources. Movingto 610, the search system parses the search results to determineattributes associated with each of the search results. Continuing to612, the search system classifies (categorizes) the search results basedon the determined attributes. Advancing to 614, the search systemoptionally filters the search results based on user preferences derivedfrom user interactions. Continuing to 616, the search system providesthe search results to a destination device based on the attributes foruser interaction via a search results user interface. For example, thesearch system may generate a graphical user interface, including controloptions and other data related to the search results, which can be sentto the destination device. The method terminates at 618.

FIG. 7 is a flow diagram of a fourth particular illustrative embodimentof a method of searching data sources. At 702, a search system providesa search interface to a destination device via a network, where thesearch interface includes search results. Moving to 704, the searchsystem receives an input selection that is related to the searchresults. Advancing to 706, the search system determines whether theinput selection is equal to a text input. If the input selection is atext input, the method advances to 708 and the search system generates anew query within the search results to refine search results. The methodadvances to 702 and the search system provides a search interfaceincluding the search results to the destination device.

In a particular embodiment, at 706, the input may be an attribute, adate, or other information that is translated to a text input.Additionally, the translated text input may be used to generate anancillary query. For example, particular search results may betangentially interesting to a user, but may not be a primary goal of aparticular search. The search system can allow a user to perform anancillary query and to view results of that query, without displacingthe original search results.

Returning to 706, if the input selection is not a text input, the methodadvances to 710 and the search system determines whether the inputselection is a selected document. If the input selection is a selecteddocument, the method advances to 712 and the search system provides dataassociated with the selected document that is related to the inputselection to the destination device. Proceeding to 714, the searchsystem receives an input selection that is related to the data.Advancing to 716, the search system determines if the input selection isrelated to an instruction to return to the search interface. If theinput selection indicates a return to the search interface, the methodadvances to 702 and the search system provides a search interfaceincluding the search results to the destination device. If the inputselection is not a return to interface selection, the method advances to718 and the document is provided to the destination device. The methodterminates at 720.

Returning to 710, if the input selection is not related to a selecteddocument, the method advances to 722 and the search system determines ifthe input selection is related to a navigation tab. If the inputselection is not related to a navigation tab, the method returns to 704.If the input selection is related to a navigation tab at 722, the methodadvances to 724 and the search system determines an application set thatis associated with the selected navigation tab. For example, a graphicaluser interface may include a tab that is related to graphical maps and asecond tab that is related to analysis of search results. Selection ofeither the graphical maps or the analysis tabs requires the system todetermine a context and an application set associated with the selectedtab. Proceeding to 726, the search system generates an applicationinterface including multiple selectable view options and including thesearch results. Advancing to 728, the search system provides theapplication interface to the destination device. The method terminatesat 720.

In a particular illustrative embodiment, the search system can infer adesired interface to present to the user, either based upon userpreferences, user history, or the data retrieved. For example, financialdata related to the search may be presented within a graphical userinterface in a chart, a graph, or spreadsheet form, based on theinferences made by the search system.

FIG. 8 is a flow diagram of a fifth particular illustrative embodimentof a method of searching data sources. At 802, the search systemprovides a graphical user interface that includes a list of storedsearches related to a user's previous searches and including selectableindicators related to each item in the list of searches. The selectableindicators can include a save indicator to save a particular search, anemail indicator to share a particular search, an edit indicator torename or alter a particular search, and a delete indicator to delete aparticular search from the list of searches.

Advancing to 804, the search system receives an input selection that isrelated to one the selectable indicators that is associated with aparticular search. Proceeding to 806, the search system determineswhether the input selection is an edit name selection. If the inputselection is an edit name selection, the method advances to 808 and apop-up window is provided that includes a text input to receive a nameinput and other data. Continuing to 810, the search system receives aninput that is related to the pop-up window. Moving to 812, the searchsystem determines whether a change is entered. If no change is entered,the method returns to 804. If a change is entered, the method advancesto 814 and the search system stores the change before returning to 804.

Returning to 806, if the input selection does not refer to a namechange, the method advances to 816 and the search system determines ifthe input selection is related to sharing a search. If the inputselection is related to sharing a search, the method advances to 818 andthe search system provides a pop-up window that includes a text input toreceive an e-mail address input. The search system may share storedsearch information with an account associated with the entered e-mailaddress. The method advances to 810 and the search system receives aninput that is related to the pop-up window. Advancing to 812, the searchsystem determines if a change has been received, and if not, it methodadvances to 804. Otherwise, the method proceeds to 814 and the change isstored before the method returns to 804. In a particular illustrativeembodiment, the search system may transmit an alert to a destinationdevice associated with another user based on the email address input, tonotify the other user of the shared search information.

Returning to 820, if the input selection is not an e-mail selection, themethod proceeds to 822 and the search system determines if the inputselection is a delete search selection. If the input selection is adelete search selection, advancing to 824 a pop-up window is displayedto confirm deletion of the search. Proceeding to 826, the search systemdetermines if the deletion is confirmed, and if not, the method returnsto 812 to determine if a change has been made. If no change has beenmade, the method returns to 802, and the search system provides agraphical user interface (GUI) including the list of searches. At 812,if a change is made, the method advances to 814 and the search systemstores the change. The method returns to 804. If at 826 a confirmationis received, the search is deleted from the list. Advancing to 814, thesearch system stores the change.

Returning to 822, if the input selection is not a delete selection, themethod advances to 830, and the search system displays the searchresults. The method terminates at 832.

FIG. 9 is a flow diagram of a sixth particular illustrative embodimentof a method of searching data sources. At 902, a search system providesa graphical user interface to a destination device. The graphical userinterface can include a text input and a map having multiple selectablegraphic elements, where each selectable graphic element is related to acategory of information. Advancing to 904, the search system receives aninput. Moving to 906 the search system determines whether the input istext input, and if so, the method advances to 914 and one or more datasources are queried based on the text input. The method proceeds to 912,and the search system receives a set of search results related to thequery. Returning to 906, if the text input is not text, the methodadvances to 908 and the search system determines a category ofinformation associated with the selected element. Proceeding to 910, thesearch system queries one or more data sources based on the determinedcategory of information.

Advancing to 912, the search system receives a set of search results.Proceeding to 916, the search system determines attributes related toeach search result of the set of search results. Moving to 918, thesearch result categorizes each search result of the set of searchresults. Continuing to 920, the search system determines if the numberof categories is greater than one. If the number of categories is notgreater than one, the method advances to 922 and the search systemdisplays a list related to the search results. The method terminates at924.

Returning to 920, if the number of categories is greater than one, themethod advances to 926 and the search system displays the search resultsas a list or as a map having selectable graphic elements according tothe number of categories and based on user preferences. The methodterminates at 924.

In a particular illustrative embodiment, the search system may store auser preference associated with how a particular user wishes to viewsearch results. The particular user may prefer a graphical map asopposed to a list of search results. Accordingly, the search system maygenerate and provide a graphical user interface including a graphicalvisualization of the search results, where the graphical visualizationis a graphical map having multiple selectable graphic elements withwhich the particular user may interact to navigate the search results.

FIG. 10 is a flow diagram of a seventh particular illustrativeembodiment of a method of searching data sources. At 1002, the searchsystem provides a graphical user interface to a destination device,where the graphical user interface includes a text input and a graphicalmap comprising multiple selectable graphic elements. The graphical mapincludes visual representation of a data set, such as a search result,where each of the multiple selectable graphic elements is associatedwith a particular category of information related to the search results.Advancing to 1004, the search system receives data related to an inputselection. Proceeding to 1006, the search system performs a query on thedata set to produce a second data set when the input selection includestext received via the text input. In a particular illustrativeembodiment, the text input may refine the set of search results.Proceeding to 1008, a second query is preformed on the data set toproduce a third data set when the input selection comprises a selectionof one of the multiple selectable graphic elements, where the secondquery includes a search term related to the category of informationassociated with the selection. Proceeding to 1010, the search systemprovides a graphical user interface that includes one of the second dataset or the third data set. The method terminates at 1012.

FIG. 11 is a flow diagram of an eighth particular illustrativeembodiment of a method of searching data sources. At 1102, the searchsystem processes metadata from search results and associated documentsto identify correlations between the metadata. Advancing to 1104, thesearch system generates categories to organize the search result basedon the identified correlations. Proceeding to 1106, the search systemgenerates a graphical map that includes multiple selectable graphicelements where each element of the multiple selectable graphic elementsis associated with one of the categories of information. Proceeding to1108, the search system provides the graphical user interface to adestination device, where the graphical user interface includes thegraphical map, a navigation panel, and selectable indicators. Advancingto 1110, the search system receives an input from a destination devicebased on a user selection. Advancing to 1112, the search systemdetermines if the selection is related to a graphic element. If so, themethod advances to 1114 and the search system drills through to acategory associated with a selection to produce a subset of the searchresults. The method proceeds to 1116 and the search system provides agraphical user interface to the destination device that includes adifferent subset of the search results. The method terminates at 1118.

Returning to 1112, if the selection is not related to a graphicalelement, the method advances to 1120 and the search system performs aquery within the search results to drill down to a sub-set of the searchresults. Proceeding to 1116, the search system provides the graphicaluser interface to a destination device, where the graphical userinterface includes the subset of the search results. The methodterminates at 1118.

In a particular illustrative embodiment, the search system can sort thesearch results based on correlations between attributes. For example,the graphical user interface may include menu options or selectableindicators to allow a user to interact with search results to providedifferent views of the same information. In a particular illustrativeexample, the search system may correlate an assignee of a patent withthe financial records associated with the assignee. In a particularexample, a menu option may allow a user to sort the search results basedon data that is not part of the original document set (i.e. not part ofthe search results). For example, the menu option may allow a user tosort based on financial data included in financial records associatedwith the companies identified from the search results, to view subsetsof the information within the document space or to map the subset of theinformation to a visualization. The graphical user interface may beadapted to allow a user to interact with the data set to sort, filterand display the same information in multiple different ways.

FIG. 12 is a flow diagram of a ninth particular illustrative embodimentof a method of searching data sources. At 1202, the search systemprovides a graphical user interface to a destination device, where thegraphical user interface includes a list of search results related afirst query and where each item in the list of search results includes aselectable rating indicator. Advancing to 1204, the search systemreceives one or more selections that are related to the selectablerating indicators from the list of search results. Proceeding to 1206,the search system processes documents associated with the list of searchresults to identify search terms and to determine a relevance rank ofeach of the identified search terms based on the one or more selections.Advancing to 1208, the search system automatically generates a secondquery based on identified search terms. In a particular illustrativeembodiment, the secondary query may be based on ownership dataassociated with particular documents to retrieve financial informationand other data that may be correlated to the search results. Proceedingto 1210, the search system uses the search results from the second queryto augment the search results from the first query. Advancing to 1212,the search system provides the search results from the search firstquery and the second query to the destination device. The methodterminates at 1214.

FIG. 13 is a flow diagram of a tenth particular illustrative embodimentof a method of searching data sources. At 1302, a search system providesa graphical user interface to a destination device that includes avisualization menu in search results, where the search results includeunstructured data. Advancing to 1304, the search system receives datathat is related to a selection from the visualization menu. Proceedingto 1306, the search system generates a first visualization that isrelated to the search results based on the data. The first visualizationmay include a graphical map having multiple selectable graphic elementscorresponding to information derived from the search results. Proceedingto 1308, the search system provides the graphical user interface to thedestination device that includes the visualization menu and the firstvisualization. Advancing to 1310, the search system receives data thatis related to a second selection from the visualization menu. At 1312,the search system generates a second visualization that is related tothe search results, where the second visualization includes a graphicalmap having multiple selectable graphical elements corresponding toinformation derived from the search results. Proceeding to 1314, thesearch system provides a graphical user interface to the destinationdevice that includes the visualization menu and the secondvisualization. The method terminates at 1316.

FIG. 14 is a flow diagram of an eleventh particular illustrativeembodiment of a method of searching data sources. At 1402, a searchsystem receives search results that are related to a query, where eachsearch result has an associated document. Proceeding to 1404, the searchsystem extracts data that is related to the document for each searchresult. Advancing to 1406, the search system queries a database toretrieve secondary data related to the extracted data. Proceeding to1408, the search system augments the search results with retrieved datafrom the database. Continuing to 1410, the search system correlates theretrieved data with the extracted data to generate categories for thesearch results and to relate each search result to one or more of thecategories. Proceeding to 1412, the search system provides a graphicaluser interface to a destination device that includes a search resultsand includes a control panel organized according to the categories,where the control panel includes selectable indicators related to thecategories for adjusting the displayed search results. In a particularillustrative embodiment, the control panel may permit a user to negateparticular results (i.e. to filter the results to exclude particularinformation) by selecting a particular category within a control panel,for example. Advancing to 1414, the search system receives data that isrelated to a selected one of the selectable indicators from the controlpanel. Advancing to 1416, the search system filters the search resultsaccording to the data. Continuing to 1418, the search system provides agraphical user interface to the destination device that includes theselectable search results, except for the search results associated witha category related to the selected one of the selectable indicators. Themethod terminates at 1420.

FIG. 15 is a flow diagram of a twelfth particular illustrativeembodiment of a method of searching data sources. At 1502, the searchsystem receives search results from one or more data sources. Advancingto 1504, the search system derives a rule from explicit and implicituser actions and applies the rule to the search results to produce amatrix that includes highest probability key words identified from thesearch results. Continuing to 1506, the search system selects the searchresults having a desired coverage based on greedy algorithm (i.e. analgorithm to select a largest number of results). Moving to 1508, thesearch system selects a number of search results for additional userfeedback information. Continuing to 1510, the search system provides auser interface that includes a selectable ranking indicator for eachresult of the number of search results. Proceeding to 1512, the searchsystem receives data that is related to a selection from the selectableranking indicators. Continuing to 1514, the search system refines therule based on the data. Advancing to 1516, the search system applies therefined rule to filter the search results. The method terminates at1518.

FIG. 16 is a flow diagram of a thirteenth particular illustrativeembodiment of a method of searching data sources. At 1602, a searchsystem receives search results from one or more data sources. Each itemof the search results can be associated with a document, where at leastone document comprises unstructured data. The unstructured data may betext data, image data, video data, or audio data. Moving to 1604, thesearch system retrieves ancillary information from a secondary search ofat least one other data source using a query that is related to datafrom the search results. Proceeding to 1606, the search systemcorrelates the search results with the ancillary information to identifyassociations between search results to produce augmented search results.The ancillary information includes associative data that is not includedwithin the search results. Continuing to 1608, the search systemprovides a graphical user interface including the augmented searchresults to a destination device. The augmented search results caninclude data related to the ancillary information. The method terminatesat 1610.

In a particular illustrative embodiment, the document can includesemi-structured data, such as tagged documents, hypertext markuplanguage (HTML) documents, extensible markup language (XML) documents,or other semi-structured documents. In another embodiment, the searchsystem can retrieve data from a structured data source, such as adatabase, and the secondary search can include a structured databasequery. In another particular illustrative embodiment, the search systemmay retrieve data from an unstructured or variably structured datasource, such as a public network (i.e. the Internet).

In a particular illustrative embodiment, each identified associationincludes a shared attribute derived from the search results. In anotherparticular illustrative embodiment, the graphical user interfaceincludes one or more selectable indicators related to the ancillaryinformation. The one or more selectable indicators can be a button, acheck box, a radio button, or another user selectable element. The oneor more selectable indicators can be accessible to by a user to alter apresentation of the augmented search results.

In a particular illustrative embodiment, the ancillary information caninclude time-varying information, such as a current stock value. In suchan instance, the augmented search results change with the ancillaryinformation. In a particular illustrative embodiment, the search systemcan extract secondary data from documents associated with the searchresults and can send a secondary query to at least one data source basedon the secondary data. In still another particular illustrativeembodiment, the search system correlates the search results byidentifying relationships between metadata related to the searchresults. The search system can generate one or more selectableindicators from the secondary data and from the ancillary information todrill through the search results. Additionally, the search system cangenerate one or more selectable indicators from the secondary data andfrom the ancillary information to drill down within the search results.

FIG. 17 is a flow diagram of a particular illustrative embodiment of amethod of query refinement. At 1702, a search system receives datarelated to search results. Moving to 1704, the search systemautomatically generates a query based on the search results and withoutexplicit input. For example, the search system can extract data from thesearch results and formulate a query to one or more data sources basedon the extracted data. In a particular illustrative embodiment, thesearch system may extract ownership data related to assignees or ownersof particular documents from the search results and search for ancillaryinformation related to such ownership data. The ancillary informationcan include geographic information, financial information, litigationhistory information, and other information that is tangentially relatedto at least one attribute of the search results. Proceeding to 1706, thesearch system generates at least one visualization of second datarelated to search results from the generated query. Advancing to 1708,the search system stores a snapshot related to the second data. Themethod terminates at 1710.

In a particular illustrative embodiment, the second data may includeancillary data, data that relates (at least tangentially) to the datacontained within the search results. In a particular illustrativeembodiment, the search system automatically generates a query bygenerating a competitive intelligence query related to industryinformation extracted from the search results and searching at least onedata source using the competitive intelligence query to identify thesecond data. In a particular illustrative embodiment, the visualizationof the second data is generated based on a user profile, which mayinclude explicit and implicit user feedback derived from previouscommunications between the user and the search system. In still anotherparticular illustrative embodiment, the visualization of the second datais generated based on a user selection, such as from a visualizationmenu that includes multiple visualization options. In an illustrativeexample, the visualization can be a graphical visualization thatincludes multiple selectable graphical elements, where each selectablegraphical element is related to at least one of the search results. Thegraphical visualization can be a geographic map, a document landscape, achart, a graph, another visualization, or any combination thereof. In aparticular embodiment, the graphical visualization can be an indicatorresembling a dashboard indicator, such as a dial indicator.

FIG. 18 is a flow diagram of a particular illustrative embodiment of amethod of goal-oriented searching. At 1802, the search system provides agraphical user interface including an input and a selectable indicator.The selectable indicator may be related to a pre-defined query relatedto a particular goal, where the goal comprising multiple criteria. Forexample, the goal may include criteria to identify particular criteriafor desired search results, such as criteria for identifying companiesthat operate in the same technology market or industry as that of anowner associated with particular document. Advancing to 1804, the searchsystem receives data related to the input. Proceeding to 1806, thesearch system inserts the data into the pre-defined query to produce agoal-oriented query to identify one or more documents that satisfy themultiple criteria. Continuing to 1808, the search system provides agraphical user interface to a destination device including data relatedto the one or more documents. The method terminates at 1810.

In a particular illustrative embodiment, the goal-oriented query caninclude a competitive analysis search to identify data related tocompetitors of a particular entity, an asset licensing search toidentify data related to potential licensees of the asset, a patentinvalidity search, an asset identifying search to identify a potentiallyvaluable asset from a plurality of assets, or any combination thereof.In another particular embodiment, the multiple criteria include a datecriteria, a keyword, an industry classification, an organizationidentifier, or any combination thereof. In a particular illustrativeembodiment, the search system retrieves a first document related to thedata and performs link analysis on one or more links contained withinthe first document to extract additional information related to thepre-defined query. The first document can include semi-structured data.

FIG. 19 is a flow diagram of a second particular illustrative embodimentof a method of goal-oriented searching. At 1902, the search systemprovides a user interface to a destination device. Proceeding to 1904,the search system receives an input and an identifier related to apre-defined goal. The pre-defined goal includes multiple criteria.Advancing to 1906, the search system inserts the data into a pre-definedquery to produce a goal-oriented query constructed to identify one ormore documents that satisfy the multiple criteria. Continuing to 1908,the search system generates a report identifying data related to thesearch results from the pre-defined query. The method terminates at1910.

In a particular illustrative embodiment, the report may be a competitiveanalysis report identifying data related to competitors of a particularentity based on search results from the pre-defined query. In anotherparticular illustrative embodiment, the report may be a licensee reportidentifying data related to potential licensees of an asset based onsearch results from the pre-defined query. In still another particularillustrative embodiment, the report may be a patent invalidity reportidentifying data related to documents that may invalidate a particularpatent based on search results from the pre-defined query. In yetanother particular illustrative embodiment, the report may be an assetreport identifying data related to a potentially valuable asset from aplurality of assets based on search results from the pre-defined query.

In a particular illustrative embodiment, the method may also includeretrieving a first document related to the data and performing linkanalysis on one or more links contained within the first document toextract additional information related to the pre-defined query. In aparticular illustrative, non-limiting embodiment, the search system cantraverse the links from the first document to locate other documents.The system can traverse links in the other documents to find still moredocuments. The system can assemble a list of documents identified fromthe link analysis that are not contained or cited in the first document.

In a particular illustrative embodiment, the multiple criteria include alocation identifier, a range of annual revenues associated with anorganization, or a combination thereof. In another particularillustrative embodiment, the search system reverse engineers a queryfrom the one or more identified documents, which may be associated witha company that is related to the received data. In still anotherparticular illustrative embodiment, the search system queries multipledata sources using the goal-oriented query, and provides results to adestination device within a graphical user interface.

FIG. 20 is a flow diagram of a particular illustrative embodiment of amethod of presenting search results. At 2002, a search system retrievessearch results from multiple data sources, where at least one of thesearch results includes a document having unstructured data. Proceedingto 2004, the search system extracts data from the search results. Movingto 2006, the search system dynamically generates a graphical userinterface (GUI) including a visualization of data related to the searchresults and including multiple selectable options related to theextracted data. The multiple selectable options can be accessed to alterthe visualization. Advancing to 2008, the search system provides agraphical user interface to a destination device via a network. Themethod terminates 2010.

In a particular illustrative embodiment, the multiple selectable optionsinclude a negation option related to a classification. The negationoption is accessible to remove data related to the search results thatare associated with the classification from the presentation. In anotherparticular illustrative embodiment, the multiple selectable optionscomprise an industry classification option, which is based on industrycategories associated with owners of documents related to the searchresults. The multiple selectable options may also include a documentsource option, which is related to a data source from which a particularsearch result is received. In still another particular embodiment, themultiple selectable options include a company classification optionbased on company names associated with owners of documents related tothe search results. In yet another particular embodiment, the multipleselectable options include a geographic location option that relates toa geographic location associated with owners of documents related to thesearch results. For example, a corporate assignee of a patent has anaddress that represents a geographic location.

In a particular illustrative embodiment, the multiple selectable optionsinclude a slider bar that is accessible by a user to select among arange of values to control a presentation of the search results. Inanother particular illustrative embodiment, the method can includeextracting data from the search results, generating a query related tothe extracted data, and retrieving ancillary data from at least one datasource based on the generated query. The ancillary data includes atleast one classification. In a particular illustrative embodiment, thesearch system may provide a graphical user interface (GUI) that includesdata representing statistics derived from the search results.

FIG. 21 is a flow diagram of a second particular illustrative embodimentof a method of presenting search results. At 2102, a search systemextracts attributes from search results retrieved from multiple datasources. The multiple data sources include a data source that includes adocument. Proceeding to 2104, the search system associates each of thesearch results with one or more classifications. In a particularembodiment, some of the search results may be associated with multipleclassifications. Advancing to 2106, the search system generates agraphical user interface including data related to the search resultsand including multiple selectable control options. Each of the multipleselectable control options may be related to an extracted attribute fromthe search results or may be related to a classification. Continuing to2108, the search system provides the graphical user interface to adestination device. The method terminates at 2110.

In a particular illustrative embodiment, the multiple selectable controloptions can include a negation option associated with a subset of searchresults. The negation option can be accessible to filter (“negate”) thesubset from the search results. In another particular illustrativeembodiment, the multiple selectable control options include an industrycontrol option accessible to view data related to search resultsassociated with an industry classification. In another particularembodiment, the multiple selectable control options include a companycontrol option accessible to view data related to search resultsassociated with a particular company. In yet another particularillustrative embodiment, the multiple selectable control options caninclude a location control option accessible to view data related tosearch results associated with a particular location, a date option tolimit the search results based on at least one date, a financial controloption to filter the search results based on financial informationassociated with owners of documents related to the search results.

FIG. 22 is a flow diagram of a third particular illustrative embodimentof a method of presenting search results. At 2202, a search systemidentifies data related to search results from one or more data sources,which includes at least one document data source. Proceeding to 2204,the search system provides an interface to present multiple views of thedata, where a first view and a second view from the multiple viewspresent the data in different contexts. The method terminates at 2206.

In a particular illustrative embodiment, the different contexts includea geographical context, which includes a visualization to map attributesof the search results to a geographic map. In another particularembodiment, the different contexts include a financial contextrepresenting revenues of organizations associated with the data, anindustry context representing a list of companies organized by industryclassification associated with the data, and a business intelligencecontext. The business intelligence context can be used to map particularresources of an organization against resources of other organizations toidentify opportunities, threats, risks, opportunities, otherintelligence, or any combination thereof.

In a particular illustrative embodiment, the interface includes avisualization adjustment option to modify a parameter of a selected viewof the multiple views. The parameter may include a color rangeidentifying color gradients of graphic elements within the selectedview, a sort order of data elements within the selected view, a sizedimension associated with graphic elements within the selected view, atexture parameter associated with graphic elements within the selectedview. The texture parameter may be represented by shading orcross-hatching, by lines, dots, or patterns, by other patterns, or anycombination thereof.

In a particular illustrative embodiment, the first view and a third viewof the multiple views may present different portions of the data. In oneembodiment, the first view may present a list of search results, whilethe third view may display financial information related to owners ofthe documents identified by the search results.

In another particular illustrative embodiment, the search systemidentifies data related to search results from one or more data sources.The one or more data sources include at least one document data source.The search system may also provide an interface to present multipleviews of the data. A first view of the multiple views and a second viewof the multiple views can present different portions of the data. Athird view and the second view from the multiple views present the datain different contexts. In another particular illustrative embodiment,the search system can augment the search results with relatedinformation to produce augmented information, and the interface presentsmultiple views of the augmented information. The search system mayretrieve ancillary data related to the search results.

In a particular illustrative embodiment, the different contexts includea cluster visualization context to present a graphical image of relateddocument clusters based on the search results, a competitiveintelligence context to present a set of organizations in a particularmarket related to the search results, a legal risk context to prioritizeinformation related to the search results based on a risk assessment, orany combination thereof. Further, the different contents can include atree map analysis context to display a correlation between searchresults and an asset valuation context to identify potentialmonetization opportunities for selected assets related to the searchresults, or any combination thereof.

FIG. 23 is a flow diagram of a fourth particular illustrative embodimentof a method of presenting search results. At 2303, a search system canprovide a graphical user interface including a first view of datarelated to search results. The first view includes multiple selectablegraphic elements, such as graphical images, buttons, graphs, otherselectable indicators, or any combination thereof. Proceeding to 2304,the search system receives an input related to a selected graphicelement. Moving to 2306, the search system provides a second view of thedata in response to receiving the input. The second view provides asecond context for the data. Advancing to 2308, the search systemprovides a third view of the data in response to a second input, wherethe third view presents a visualization of the data that is differentfrom the first view. The method terminates at 2310.

In a particular illustrative embodiment, the second view includes asubset of the search results, a portion of the data related to thesearch results, an expanded view of the search results, or anycombination thereof. In a particular illustrative embodiment, the secondview includes a different set of search results based on an attribute ofthe data from the first view.

FIGS. 24-39 are diagrams of particular illustrative embodiments ofgraphical user interfaces to search data sources. Each of theillustrative embodiments includes multiple selectable indicators oroptions, which a user may select to access particular functions orfeatures. It should be understood that other graphical user interfacesand other selectable options can be provided, depending on theparticular implementation. Additionally, each of multiple selectableoptions may be used in any of the embodiments.

FIG. 24 is a diagram of a particular illustrative embodiment of aparticular illustrative embodiment of a graphical user interface 2400 tosearch data sources. The graphical user interface 2400 includes a window2402 that includes a text input 2404, and user selectable tabs 2406,2408, 2410, and 2412. A “My Home” tab 2412 is selected and a panel 2414associated with the subscriber's home is displayed. The “My Home” tab2412 includes selectable links 2416 that are related to functionality ofthe tabs 2406, 2408, and 2410. Additionally, the “My Home” panel 2414includes selectable search shortcuts 2418 such as interactive landscapes(i.e. maps, charts, and other visualizations), personalized searching,search result analysis, and tutorials. Additionally, the “My Home” panel2414 includes saved analysis area 2420, a messages in-box area 2422, andstored search history area 2424.

The search history area 2424 may include a stored snapshot associatedwith a search, such as a search snapshot associated with “MP-3 players,”which was stored on Jan. 15, 2007. Each stored search snapshot isassociated with the user selectable icons including an information icon2426, a sharing icon 2428, an e-mail icon 2430, and a trash icon 2432. Auser may select one or more of the selectable indicators to interactwith the graphical user interface 2400. For example, the user may clickthe info icon 2426 to change the name or otherwise alter informationrelated to the stored search history. The user may share the search withother users by clicking on the share icon 2428. The user may e-mail thesearch results to another user by clicking on the e-mail icon 2430, orthe user may delete the search by clicking on the delete icon 2432.Additionally, the user may access other aspects of the search system byclicking on one or more of the selectable indicators. For example, auser may access the text input 2404 to search for particular data usingkeywords. Alternatively, a user may select one of the tabs to viewsearch results from multiple different perspectives.

In a particular embodiment, a user may utilize the tabs 2406, 2408,2410, and 2412 to switch between search results, a graphicalvisualization of the search results (e.g., a graphical user interfaceincluding a graphical map having multiple selectable elements), andvarious analyses of the search results. Additionally, a user may accessone of the research shortcuts 2416 to begin a search.

FIG. 25 is diagram of a second particular illustrative embodiment of agraphical user interface 2500 to search data sources. The graphical userinterface 2500 is adapted to interact with a back-end system that may bedirected to intellectual property, such as patents. In particular, thegraphical user interface 2500 includes the window 2402 that has an“Analysis” panel 2502. The panel 2502 includes a “patent invalidityanalysis” selectable indicator 2504, which may be utilized to perform aone-click goal-oriented search to identify a list of potentiallyinvalidating prior art for a particular patent. The panel 2502 alsoincludes a “patent licensing” selectable indicator 2506, which may beaccessed to perform a one-click goal oriented search to identify a listof likely infringers of a particular patent. Additionally, the analysispanel 2512 may include stored analysis 2508, as well as selectableoptions to start a new analysis 2510, to import documents 2512, and toimport document numbers 2514.

In a particular illustrative embodiment, in response to receiving datarelated to a selection of the patent invalidity analysis option 2504,the graphical user interface 2500 may display a popup window to receivea patent number of a patent to invalidate. The patent number may besubmitted to the search system, which retrieves the patent from theUnited States Patent and Trademark Office website, analyzes referencescited within the retrieved patent, searches the cited references andreferences cited within those cited references, and surfaces a list ofsearch results of prior art that was not cited in the patent toinvalidate. Additionally, the search system may apply additional logicto extract key terms and to retrieve search results from internationalsearch classifications associated with the patent to invalidate, eitherbased on the document itself, based on classification data (such as theNorth American Industry Classification system), or any combinationthereof. The search system may also search for documents that referencedthe particular patent and analyze documents cited by those patents orpatent publications. Additionally, the search system may provide thesearch results to the graphical user interface for display to the user.Additionally, the user may search within the search results by enteringkeywords to refine the search.

FIG. 26 is a diagram of a third particular illustrative embodiment of agraphical user interface 2600 to search data sources. The user interface2600 includes the window 2402, which includes the “search” panel 2602.The search panel 2602 includes selectable options, including astreamlined search option 2604 and a conceptual searching option 2606.The streamline searching option 2604 provides a targeted search scope toallow a user to search particular terms within a particular database.The conceptual searching option 2606 provides a broad search opportunityto identify all of the documents and not just the particular results. Inother words, the graphical user interface 2600 provides a means by whicha user can restrict or adjust search results to have high precisionand/or high recall. The search panel also includes an option to start anew search 2608 and can include a list of saved searches 2610. In aparticular illustrative embodiment, the list of saved searches 2610includes a query expansion search snapshot 2612, which can be presentedas a selectable link. Additionally, the query expansion search snapshot2612 snapshot is associated with the user selectable icons including aninformation icon 2426, a sharing icon 2428, an e-mail icon 2430, and atrash icon 2432. Additionally, a description of the query expansionsearch snapshot 2612 includes a date of the particular search snapshot,a first indicator 2614 of a number of results in the search and a secondindicator 2616 of a number of labels. In a particular illustrativeexample, a user may interact with the graphical user interface 2600 torate individual search results on a scale from irrelevant to relevant(e.g., from one star to five stars). By rating a particular searchresult, the user can label selected results.

FIG. 27 is a diagram of a fourth particular illustrative embodiment of agraphical user interface 2700 to search data sources. The graphical userinterface 2700 includes the window 2402 having a “Maps” panel 2702. Themaps panel 2702 includes multiple selectable options 2704, such as aMarkets option 2706, an industries option 2708, a companies option 2710,and a geographies option 2712. A user may select one of the selectableoptions 2704 to access particular visualizations (maps), which mayinclude multiple selectable graphic elements to view search results indifferent ways. For example, the markets option 2706 may be selected toaccess a visualization including market data associated with particularsearch results. If a user selects the industries option 2708, thegraphical user interface 2700 can display industry data related to thesearch results. If a user selects the companies option 2710, thegraphical user interface 2700 may display data about the particularcompanies. If the geographies option 2712 is selected, data can bemapped to a selectable geographic map, which may be displayed within thegraphical user interface 2700. In a particular illustrative embodiment,the graphical user interface 2700 may display legal risk and other dataassociated with a particular industry, and the graphical user interfacemay include selectable options, such as dollar ranges, sliding bars,buttons, pull-down menus, or other selectable options to adjust theparticular information.

FIG. 28 is a diagram of a fifth particular illustrative embodiment of agraphical user interface 2800 to search data sources. The graphical userinterface 2800 includes a search panel 2802 having a control panel 2804and a list of search results 2806. Each search result is associated withselectable indicators 2808 for rating the search result on a scale ofone to five stars (i.e. from “not relevant” to “relevant”). Theselectable indicators 2808 are illustrative of one possible ratingsystem. In a particular illustrative embodiment, the selectableindicators 2808 may be check boxes, radio buttons, other selectableobjects, or any combination thereof. In another particular illustrativeembodiment, the selectable indicators 2808 may be replaced with anumeric text input, a sliding bar (an adjustable element), another inputtype, or any combination thereof.

The selectable indicators 2808 allow the user to provide explicitfeedback to the search system, which can use the explicit feedback totrain a query learner and a document learner and to reverse engineer thesearch to produce new queries. In a particular illustrative embodiment,the contents of the control panel 2804 are dynamically generated by thesearch system based on the search results 2806. The control panel 2804includes statistical information, such as a bar 2814 that represents arelative number of documents associated with a particular category fromthe search results, e.g., “United States Patent Applications.”Additionally, each category may include a selectable option 2814, whicha user may select to filter out search results that correspond to aparticular category.

In a particular illustrative example, if a user selects the selectableoption 2814 that is associated with the category “U.S. Pat. App.,” thelist of search results 2806 would be adjusted to remove patentapplications from the displayed list. The selectable option 2814 may becalled a “negation” option. Each category associated with the searchresults may be separately filtered, such that the user can selectivelyfilter out “unassigned” patents and applications, particular companies,particular types of documents, other categories, or any combinationthereof. In a particular illustrative embodiment, other document sourcesmay include commercial databases, governmental databases, other datasources, or any combination thereof, which may be filtered using theselectable options 2814 that correspond with the particular categoryidentifying the respective data source. Other categories of the searchresults may include industry classifications, geographic information,date information, other information, or any combination thereof.

Referring again to FIG. 28, the graphical user interface 2800 caninclude a “SORT BY” menu option 2820 that can be accessed by a user tosort items within the list of search results 2806. Each item within thelist of search results 2806 may be related to a particular document. TheSORT BY menu option 2820 allows the user to sort the items based oninformation that may or may not be contained within the documents. The“SORT BY” menu option 2820 includes an “Organization Revenue” option, an“Organization Litigation” option, a “Classification Litigation” option,an “Expiration Date” option, an “Other” option, and a “Legal Risk”option. The Organization Revenue option allows the user to sort thesearch results based on revenues of companies that own the document(e.g., assignees of the patent documents). The Organization Litigationoption can be accessed to sort the search results based on a litigationhistory of an organization that owns the document. The ClassificationLitigation can be accessed to sort the search results based on alitigation history of the classification of the document. For example, alevel of litigation activity within a particular classification withwhich the document is associated (e.g., semiconductor devices). TheExpiration Date option can be accessed to sort the search results from aPatent Office (e.g., the United States Patent Office, the EuropeanPatent Office, other patent offices, or any combination thereof) basedon a calculated expiration date, failure to pay maintenance fees, orinvalidation. The search system can also calculate expiration dates forother types of data, such as Small Business Administration InnovativeResearch grants, which may have a request for proposal expiration date.Further, the search system can determine expiration dates related toCopyrights, Trademarks, user-defined expiration dates (such as an emailexpiration date), other expiration dates, or any combination thereof.

Other sorting options may include a number of documents associated withan organization or classification, a relevance ratings, date data,financial data, location data, author data, statistical data, referencedata, pricing data, credit history, enterprise data, employee data,litigation data, user-provided data, user-defined sorting algorithm, orany combination thereof.

The Legal Risk option can be accessed by a user to sort the searchresults based on a probabilistic determination of legal risk (e.g.,likelihood of a lawsuit, likelihood of a citation by another document,likelihood of licensing opportunities, other factors, or any combinationthereof). In a particular illustrative, non-limiting embodiment, thesearch system can evaluate the legal risk based on patents and patentpublications. In such an instance, the legal risk can be based on anumber of claims, a number prior art citations, a number of forwardreferences (e.g., references that cite the particular patent), a lengthof time between filing and grant of the patent, number of figures,number of pages, age of patent, number of inventors and informationassociated with the inventor (number of patents listing the inventor,distribution of patents within classification system, employmentrecords, number of citations from other patents, number of publicationsor work outside of patents, other data, or any combination thereof).

Additionally, in such an instance, the legal risk can be based onassignee data, such as litigation history, financial history, entitytype (e.g. university, small business, non-profit organization,inventor), local or foreign location, number of patents, number ofcitations from other publications, number of publications outside ofpatents, associations with industry standards, number of products,number of inventors, number of employees, other data, or any combinationthereof. Also, in such an instance, the legal risk can be based onassignee data or the absence thereof. Further, the legal risk can bebased on classification data, including litigation history, number ofpatents, number of citations, number of inventors, other data, or anycombination thereof, within a particular classification. Additionally,the legal risk can be based on location data, including geographic data,logic geographic groupings (such as legal jurisdictions), litigationhistory data, country-based data (e.g., international laws,country-specific laws, treaties, other groupings, or any combinationthereof), financial information, proximity to universities (i.e.proximity to intellectual talent pool), other categories, or anycombination thereof. Additionally, the legal risk can be related touser-provided data or user-assigned rankings. In a particularembodiment, any of the above-listed factors may be used in anycombination to evaluate legal risk.

In a particular instance, the Legal Risk option can be selected toaccess an associated submenu 2822, from which the user may specify anascending or a descending order for the sorted results. Depending onwhich menu option is selected from the SORT BY menu 2820, other submenusand related sorting options can be accessed, allowing a user to view thesame data in a variety of different ways.

FIG. 29 is a diagram of a sixth particular illustrative embodiment of agraphical user interface 2900 to search data sources. The graphical userinterface 2900 includes a visualization panel 2902 to display multiplevisualizations of particular search results, such as the documentlandscape map 2904, and includes a control panel 2906. The documentlandscape map 2904 includes multiple selectable graphical elements, suchas the selectable graphical element 2910 to access documents associatedwith a particular classification or category of the search results. Thegraphical user interface 2900 also includes a menu of selectable options2908 for selecting between visualizations. The available visualizationsthat can be accessed using the menu of selectable options 2908 caninclude a document landscape visualization, an industry statisticsvisualization, a company clustering visualization, a companyclassifications visualization, a company “heat graph” visualization, aworld map visualization, a market landscape visualization, a“strengths-weaknesses-opportunities-threats” (SWOT) visualization, amarket-share timeline visualization, a classification trendsvisualization, a company trends visualization, a topic trendsvisualization, a location trends visualization, a source trendsvisualization, and a legal trends visualization. Visualizations may beadded or omitted, depending on the particular implementation.

In a particular illustrative embodiment, each of the multiple selectablegraphic elements, including the selectable graphic element 2910, has asize dimension indicating a relative number of documents associated withthe particular category of information. Each of the selectable graphicelements may also have a respective color dimension, shading dimension,hatching dimension, or other visual indicator that represents therelative number of documents.

In a particular illustrative embodiment, the control panel 2906 providesmultiple selectable options, including selectable classificationnegation options, selectable date options and other options. Selectionof one of the selectable classification negation options causes thegraphical user interface 2900 to display a document landscape 2904 thatis adjusted according to the selection.

FIG. 30 is a diagram of a seventh particular illustrative embodiment ofa graphical user interface 3000 to search data sources. The graphicaluser interface 3000 includes the control panel 2906 and an industrystatistics visualization panel 3002 including industry average financialinformation 3004 and a list of top industries 3006 within a particularset of search results. The search system may retrieve financial data forthe industry statistics visualization panel 3002 using a secondarysearch query derived from data extracted from search results related toa first (primary) query. The financial data can relate to companiesbased on ownership information extracted from the search results. Forexample, a search of the United States Patent Office patents databasefor particular keywords results in a list of search results. The searchsystem can extract ownership data from the documents related to thesearch results and can search a financial database based on theownership information to determine industry statistics corresponding tothe search results. The control panel 2906 can include one or moreslider control options 3008, which may be adjusted to define a parameterrelated to data associated with the search results, such as thefinancial data. For example, the slider control options 3008 may beadjusted to define a financial range, which may be used to filter theresults.

FIG. 31 is a diagram of an eighth particular illustrative embodiment ofa graphical user interface 3100 to search data sources. The graphicaluser interface 3100 includes the control panel 2906 a company clusteringvisualization 3102, which displays search result data based on theownership data. In particular, the company clustering visualizationincludes multiple selectable graphic elements, such as the selectablegraphic element 3104. The graphical user interface 3100 may produce acallout when a pointer is placed over a particular selectable indicator.For example, when the pointer is placed over the selectable graphicelement 3104, a callout 3106 is displayed indicating that the selectablegraphic element 3104 is related to documents associated with IBMCorporation. Each selectable graphic element, including the selectablegraphic element 3104, can include a size dimension, a color dimension, ashading dimension, a hatching dimension, an other visual dimension, orany combination thereof, indicating a relative size of a document spacefor a particular company relative to other companies represented withinthe search results. In a particular illustrative embodiment, the usermay access the callout to provide a user input. The search system canassociate the user input to the selectable graphic element, such as theselectable graphic element 3104, allowing the user to label or tag data.The search system can utilize such explicit user feedback for dataretrieval, data classification, and personalized searching.

FIG. 32 is a diagram of a ninth particular illustrative embodiment of agraphical user interface 3200 to search data sources. The graphical userinterface 3200 includes the control panel 2906 and a companyclassification timeline visualization panel 3202, which includes atimeline chart 3204 having multiple selectable indicators, such as theselectable indicator 3206. The timeline chart 3204 represents a timelineof document categories for each company represented within the searchresults. In a particular illustrative embodiment, the selectableindicator 3206 may be selected to access documents associated with theparticular category for the year 2002 and for the particular company,Koninklijke Philips Electronics NV. In general, the control panel 2906may be used to filter the search results, which changes the data shownat the company classification timeline visualization panel 3202.

FIG. 33 is a diagram of a tenth particular illustrative embodiment of agraphical user interface 3300 to search data sources. The graphical userinterface 3300 includes the control panel 2906 and a company heat graphvisualization panel 3302. In a particular illustrative embodiment, theheat graph visualization panel 3302 may represent documents associatedwith particular companies represented within the search results that arerelated to a particular United States Patent Office classification.Alternatively, the heat graph visualization panel 3302 may, whichincludes a chart 3304 that represents documents associated withparticular companies represented within the search results that arerelated to a particular industry classification, a particular subjectmatter, an other classification or category, or any combination thereof.The particular table cells may include a visual dimension, such as acolor dimension, a cross-hatching dimension, a shading dimension,another visual indication, or any combination thereof, to represent arelative size of a document space within a particular category.

FIG. 34 is a diagram of an eleventh particular illustrative embodimentof a graphical user interface 3400 to search data sources. The graphicaluser interface 3400 includes a control panel 2906 and a world mapvisualization panel 3402. The world map visualization panel 3402includes a selectable map 3404 including multiple selectable graphicelements, such as the selectable graphic element 3406, which representsa geographic cluster of documents related to the search results. Forexample, the selectable graphic element 3406 can represent documentshaving geographic attributes associated with Houston, Tex. Selection ofthe selectable graphic element 3406 causes the graphical user interface3402 to display the documents within the search results that areassociated with Houston, Tex. In a particular illustrative embodiment,the geographic association may be based on an author's address, anassignee's address, or other geographic information within a documentassociated with the search results.

FIG. 35 is a diagram of a twelfth particular illustrative embodiment ofa graphical user interface 3500 to search data sources. The graphicaluser interface 3500 includes a control panel 2906 and a market landscapevisualization panel 3502, which includes a market landscape map 3504having multiple selectable graphical indicators, such as the selectablegraphical indicator 3506. The market landscape map 3504 provides avisual representation of the search results for each company plotted ona graph based on execution (e.g., number of documents) versus aparticular category of information (e.g., industry classification,market classification, document classification, other classifications,or any combination thereof). When a pointer is positioned over theselectable graphic indicator 3506, a callout 3508 is displayed,indicating an association between the selectable graphic element 3506and a company, i.e. IBM. By selecting one of the selectable graphicelements (by clicking on the element using a mouse pointer, forexample), documents associated with the selected graphic element may bedisplayed.

FIG. 36 is a diagram of a thirteenth particular illustrative embodimentof a graphical user interface 3600 to search data sources. The graphicaluser interface 3600 includes a control panel 2906 and astrengths-weaknesses-opportunities-threats (SWOT) panel 3602. The SWOTpanel 3604 includes multiple selectable dashboard elements 3604, whichindicate aspects of a company's performance relative to other companies.The SWOT panel 3604 provides a dynamic visual representation of thesearch results, providing a different perspective on the sameinformation. The SWOT panel 3604 can be used to capture competitiveintelligence. The SWOT panel 3604 can be used to identify competitors(new entrants and existing threats) and to readily compare competitivestrengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats. The SWOT panel 3604may also be used to identify potential partners for acquiring existingtechnologies.

FIG. 37 is a diagram of a fourteenth particular illustrative embodimentof a graphical user interface 3700 to search data sources. The graphicaluser interface 3700 includes a control panel 2906 and a companyclassification timeline panel 3702, which includes a graph 3704 of thecompany's documents over time. The graph 3704 includes multipleselectable graphic elements 3706, which represent a particular company'sdocuments within a particular classification at a particular time. In aparticular embodiment, the graph 3704 may display the documentsassociated with a particular United States Patent Office classification.

FIG. 38 is a diagram of a fifteenth particular illustrative embodimentof a graphical user interface 3800 to search data sources. The graphicaluser interface 3800 includes a control panel 2906 and a classificationtrends panel 3802, including a graph 3804 having multiple selectablegraphical elements, such as the selectable graphical element 3806. In aparticular illustrative embodiment, the graph 3804 may display arelative number of classifications per company for a period of time. Ina particular embodiment, the classifications may include documentclassifications (such as United States Patent Office classifications,document classifications, subject matter classifications, otherclassifications, manual search scope, or any combination thereof). Theclassifications may be determined directly from the search results, fromNAICS industry classifications, from correlations between the searchresults and industry classifications, from other classifications (suchas pre-defined categories, abstract-based categories, keywordcategories, or other categories), or from any combination thereof.

FIG. 39 is a diagram of a sixteenth particular illustrative embodimentof a graphical user interface 3900 to search data sources. The graphicaluser interface 3900 includes a control panel 2906 and a company trendsvisualization panel 3902, including a company trends graph 3904 havingmultiple selectable graphical elements 3906. The company trends graph3904 can display information about a relative number of documents perclassification.

In general, the search system is adapted to generate multiple graphicaluser interfaces and to provide multiple visualizations of the same data.In a particular illustrative embodiment, the search system generates agraphical user interface and provides the graphical user interface to adestination device, such as remote computer, for display. In anotherparticular illustrative embodiment, the search system generates agraphical user interface and provides instructions executable by abrowser application at the destination device, which executes theinstructions to render the graphical user interface.

In a particular illustrative embodiment, each of the visualizations maybe stored by the search system as a separate module, allowing additionalvisualizations to be added on the fly (dynamically), without having tocompile the new code with the existing code. Processing logic at thesearch system can immediately implement new visualizations by providingthe up-to-date menu options each time the user device accesses thesearch system.

Additionally, while the control panel 2906 included pull-down menus,check boxes, text boxes, and buttons to interact with the searchresults, it should be understood that other selectable control elementsmay also be included in the control panel 2906. For example, the controlpanel 2906 can include a slider, a rotatable knob, a set of radiobuttons, other selectable indicators, or any combination thereof, whichmay be used to interact with the search results. In a particularembodiment, the legal trends visualization may provide insights into aparticular company's litigation history, including settlements,licensing, verdicts, number of litigations (pending, settled, or ended),other information, or any combination thereof. Particular selectableelements may be provided to interact with particular aspects of theinformation to adjust the search results to identify particularinformation. For example, in a particular illustrative, non-limitingembodiment, a slider may be adjusted to identify companies that haveless than five previous litigation matters, that have settled for$20,000 to $50,000, that have lost jury verdicts in excess of$10,000,000, or any combination thereof.

In a particular illustrative embodiment, the search system may beimplemented as a single server adapted to execute multiple programmodules. In another particular embodiment, the search system may beimplemented using multiple servers (“a server system”) in which variousfunctions may be balanced across the multiple servers. In an alternativeembodiment, dedicated hardware implementations, such as applicationspecific integrated circuits, programmable logic arrays and otherhardware devices, can be constructed to implement one or more of themethods described herein. Applications that may include the apparatusand systems of various embodiments can broadly include a variety ofelectronic and computer systems. One or more embodiments describedherein may implement functions using two or more specific interconnectedhardware modules or devices with related control and data signals thatcan be communicated between and through the modules, or as portions ofan application-specific integrated circuit. Accordingly, the presentsystem encompasses software, firmware, and hardware implementations.

In accordance with various embodiments of the present disclosure, themethods described herein may be implemented by software programsexecutable by a computer system. Further, in an exemplary, non-limitedembodiment, implementations can utilize distributed processing,component/object distributed processing, and parallel processing.Alternatively, virtual computer system processing can be constructed toimplement one or more of the methods or functionality as describedherein. Additionally, the present disclosure contemplates acomputer-readable medium that includes instructions or receives andexecutes instructions responsive to a propagated signal, so that adevice connected to a network can receive and execute the instructions.

While the computer-readable medium is shown to be a single medium, theterm “computer-readable medium” includes a single medium or multiplemedia, such as a centralized or distributed database, and/or associatedcaches and servers that store one or more sets of instructions. The term“computer-readable medium” shall also include any medium that is capableof storing, encoding or carrying a set of instructions for execution bya processor or that cause a computer system to perform any one or moreof the methods or operations disclosed herein.

Although the present specification describes components and functionsthat may be implemented in particular embodiments with reference toparticular standards and protocols, the disclosed embodiments are notlimited to such standards and protocols. For example, standards forInternet and other packet switched network transmission (e.g., TCP/IP,UDP/IP, HTML, HTTP) represent examples of the state of the art. Suchstandards are periodically superseded by faster or more efficientequivalents having essentially the same functions. Accordingly,replacement standards and protocols having the same or similar functionsas those disclosed herein are considered equivalents thereof.

The illustrations of the embodiments described herein are intended toprovide a general understanding of the structure of the variousembodiments. The illustrations are not intended to serve as a completedescription of all of the elements and features of apparatus and systemsthat utilize the structures or methods described herein. Many otherembodiments may be apparent to those of skill in the art upon reviewingthe disclosure. Other embodiments may be utilized and derived from thedisclosure, such that structural and logical substitutions and changesmay be made without departing from the scope of the disclosure.Additionally, the illustrations are merely representational and may notbe drawn to scale. Certain proportions within the illustrations may beexaggerated, while other proportions may be reduced. Accordingly, thedisclosure and the figures are to be regarded as illustrative ratherthan restrictive.

Although specific embodiments have been illustrated and describedherein, it should be appreciated that any subsequent arrangementdesigned to achieve the same or similar purpose may be substituted forthe specific embodiments shown. This disclosure is intended to cover anyand all subsequent adaptations or variations of various embodiments.Combinations of the above embodiments, and other embodiments notspecifically described herein, will be apparent to those of skill in theart upon reviewing the description.

The Abstract of the Disclosure is provided to comply with 37 C.F.R.§1.72(b) and is submitted with the understanding that it will not beused to interpret or limit the scope or meaning of the claims. Inaddition, in the foregoing Detailed Description, various features may begrouped together or described in a single embodiment for the purpose ofstreamlining the disclosure. This disclosure is not to be interpreted asreflecting an intention that the claimed embodiments require morefeatures than are expressly recited in each claim. Rather, as thefollowing claims reflect, inventive subject matter may be directed toless than all of the features of any of the disclosed embodiments. Thus,the following claims are incorporated into the Detailed Description,with each claim standing on its own as defining separately claimedsubject matter.

The above-disclosed subject matter is to be considered illustrative, andnot restrictive, and the appended claims are intended to cover all suchmodifications, enhancements, and other embodiments, which fall withinthe true spirit and scope of the present invention. Thus, to the maximumextent allowed by law, the scope of the present invention is to bedetermined by the broadest permissible interpretation of the followingclaims and their equivalents, and shall not be restricted or limited bythe foregoing detailed description.

1. A system to present search results, the system comprising: a searchsystem to retrieve search results from multiple data sources based on auser query and to extract data from the search results, the searchsystem configured to retrieve ancillary data related to the searchresults from a database separate from the multiple data sources inresponse to extraction of the data and independent of the user query,the ancillary data comprising associative data that is not includedwithin the search results, the search system, in response to extractingthe data from the search results, normalizes the data into an internalformat, populates one or more temporary tables with the data mapped toan internal format, inserts the ancillary data into the one or moretemporary tables, and dynamically creates correlations between dataelements of the one or more temporary tables; and a visualization systemadapted to communicate with the search system and configured to generatea graphical user interface (GUI) including a first visualizationrepresenting a presentation of the data stored in the one or moretemporary tables and including multiple control options, the multiplecontrol options comprising a plurality of visualization optionscorresponding to different views of the data stored in the one or moretemporary tables, the plurality of visualization options comprising afirst option corresponding to the ancillary data and a second optionrelated to the data extracted from the search results; wherein the firstoption is accessible by a user to alter the presentation of the searchresults from the first visualization to a second visualization includingthe ancillary data.
 2. The system of claim 1, wherein the secondvisualization comprises revenue data related to companies identifiedwithin the search results.
 3. The system of claim 1, wherein themultiple control options comprise a negation option related to acategory of the data extracted from the search results, the negationoption is accessible by the user to remove search results associatedwith the category.
 4. The system of claim 1, wherein the search systemis configured to perform a second search based on the data extractedfrom the search results to retrieve the ancillary information, whereinthe multiple control options further comprise a third option accessibleby the user to narrow the search results based on the ancillary data. 5.The system of claim 1, wherein the multiple control options furthercomprise a snapshot storage option to store a snapshot related to searchlogic of a particular search.
 6. The system of claim 1, furthercomprising a context switching option to change between views of thesearch results.
 7. The system of claim 1, wherein the multiple controloptions comprise a third control option to adjust a view of data relatedto the search results.
 8. The system of claim 7, wherein the thirdcontrol option is accessible to adjust a color of selected graphicelements within the view.
 9. The system of claim 7, wherein the thirdcontrol option is accessible to adjust a shading of selected graphicelements within the view.
 10. The system of claim 1, wherein the searchsystem is configured to generate a secondary query based on the dataextracted from the search results to retrieve the ancillary data,wherein the multiple control options comprise a slider bar related to arange of values extracted from the ancillary data, and accessible by theuser to refine the search results over the range of values.
 11. Thesystem of claim 10, wherein each search result is associated with adocument, wherein the ancillary data includes revenue informationassociated with companies that are associated with the search results,and wherein the slider bar is accessible by the user to filter thesearch results based on the revenue information.
 12. The system of claim1, wherein the first option is accessible by the user to select betweena plurality of visualizations of the search results; and wherein atleast one of the plurality of visualizations including a thirdvisualization of the search results and the ancillary data.
 13. A methodof presenting search results, the method comprising: receiving searchresults from multiple data sources based on a user query; extractingdata from the search results in response to receiving the searchresults; retrieving ancillary data from at least one database inresponse to extracting the data from the search results, the ancillarydata comprising associative data that is not included within the searchresults; normalizing the data from the search results to an internalformat to produce normalized data in response to extracting the data;populating one or more temporary tables with the normalized data and theancillary data in response to normalizing the data; generatingcorrelations within the normalized data and between the normalized dataand the ancillary data in response to populating the one or moretemporary tables; and dynamically generating a graphical user interfaceincluding a first visualization representing the data stored in the oneor more temporary tables and including multiple control elements relatedto the extracted data, wherein the multiple control elements comprise afirst control element accessible by a user to select between a pluralityof visualizations corresponding to different views the search resultsand the ancillary data, the plurality of visualizations including a listview and a map view.
 14. The method of claim 13, further comprisingproviding the graphical user interface to a destination device, whereinthe graphical user interface includes the visualization and the multiplecontrol elements.
 15. The method of claim 13, wherein the multiplecontrol elements further comprise a selectable negation option relatedto a category associated with a subset of the search results, theselectable negation option accessible by the user to remove the subsetfrom the search results.
 16. The method of claim 13, wherein themultiple control elements further comprise a selectable snapshot optionaccessible by the user to store search logic associated with a search.17. The method of claim 13, wherein the multiple control elementsfurther comprise a selectable sharing option accessible by the user toshare search results with another user.
 18. A method of presentingsearch results, the method comprising: receiving search results relatedto a user query; retrieving ancillary data from a database in responseto receiving the search results, the ancillary data comprisingassociative data that is not included within the search results;extracting data from the search results in response to receiving thesearch results; normalizing the data to an internal format in responseto extracting the data populating one or more temporary tables with thedata and the ancillary data in response to normalizing the data;generating correlations between the data and between the data and theancillary data in response to populating the one or more temporarytables; and generating a graphical user interface (GUI) including thesearch results and the ancillary data related to the search results in afirst visualization, the GUI including multiple selectable controloptions accessible by a user, the multiple selectable control optionsincluding a first option to select between a plurality of visualizationsrepresenting different views of at least one of the search results andthe ancillary data, the multiple selectable options further including asecond option to refine the search results.
 19. The method of claim 18,wherein the multiple selectable options comprise a selectableprecision/recall option to refine the search results to control a numberof search results and a relative precision of each search resultpresented within the GUI.
 20. The method of claim 18, furthercomprising: extracting data from the search results; retrieving theancillary data from at least one data source based on the data extractedfrom the search results, the ancillary data not included within thesearch results; and associating the ancillary data with the searchresults; wherein the multiple selectable options comprise avisualization selection option accessible to switch to a secondvisualization that includes the ancillary data.
 21. The method of claim18, wherein the multiple selectable control options include arecommendation option to recommend one of a data source, a user, acompany, and an industry based on a context of the search results. 22.The method of claim 18, wherein the multiple selectable control optionscomprise selectable graphical elements related to data derived from thesearch results.
 23. The method of claim 22, wherein at least one of theselectable graphical elements is accessible by the user to change a viewof the search results from a text view to a chart view.
 24. The methodof claim 18, wherein the multiple selectable control options furthercomprise selectable ratings indicators accessible by the user to provideexplicit user feedback related to one of the search results.
 25. Themethod of claim 24, wherein the multiple selectable control optionsfurther comprise an analytics option accessible by the user to initiatetraining of a learner system based on the explicit user feedback. 26.The method of claim 18, wherein the multiple selectable control optionsfurther comprise a user input option accessible by the user to associateuser input with one of the search results.